View Full Version : Should I repaint my car to original?
ahainline 11/16/2007, 11:36 AM My GT/CS was repainted Candy Apple Red a while back (10-15 years). The paint looks decent still, a few chips here and there but nothing bad. Originally the car was Brittany Blue. I was looking at the other Marti reports and was noticing that there arent a lot of Brittany Blue GT/CS's on the site. Should I repaint mine to the original or just leave well enough alone? Also, how much should I expect to pay for a good paint job? Thanks
Tony
joedls 11/16/2007, 12:03 PM Oh no!!! Hopefully Arlie won't read this post.
Mosesatm 11/16/2007, 01:42 PM Oh no!!! Hopefully Arlie won't read this post.
Too late. I already have a call into Von Quack, but it's Friday afternoon so chances are he won't call back until Monday. I'll probably be curled up in a corner of the garage until then.
Normally I'd say to take it back to original (especially Brittany Blue!) but that is a lot of work and it may depend on how much work you want to do or money you are willing to spend. Repainting it red is cheaper, easier, and faster, but Brittany Blue is a rare and IMHO a more sophisticated color.
Need more info to estimate a price.
Is there any bodywork to do on the car? Dents, body rust, floors, fiberglass repair?
Do you want a show quality job that is hand sanded and buffed, or driver quality that may have a little orange peel?
Are you going to strip off all the old paint or paint over it?
If you have it stripped are you going to do it with a razor blade, are you going to have it chemically strippped, or blasted?
How many paint jobs are on the car now? Find a nick in the paint and see how many layers there are.
It can get real expensive real fast.
rvrtrash 11/16/2007, 06:16 PM Everything Arlie said plus, if you strip things like lights, chrome, bumpers, grill, etc. yourself, you can save some money. Figure you're paying someone $45.00-$55.00 per hour, plus materials to work on your car. If you can do some of the prep work yourself, it adds up quick. Just buying a $20.00 heat gun and spending a couple of hours removing stripes saves money. It just depends on how comfortable you feel making your car look like it's been in a chop shop. Get your estimates first though. You don't want to drive around town getting quotes with no bumpers or lights.
Steve
Perkchiro 11/16/2007, 07:21 PM So Red is not a sophisticated color Arlie? We all have a right to our opinions, but to those of us who have Red Cars. . . . . .Viva La RED!!!!!!!!
Mosesatm 11/16/2007, 07:45 PM So Red is not a sophisticated color Arlie? We all have a right to our opinions, but to those of us who have Red Cars. . . . . .Viva La RED!!!!!!!!
Steve. I did not say that red was not sophisticated. Please carefully re-read what I wrote.
The word "more" is used to compare 2 items that share a common property. If item 2 has more of something than item 1 that pretty well means that both items have some of the same thing. In this case that property is sophistication.
Midnight Special 11/16/2007, 07:54 PM So Red is not a sophisticated color Arlie? We all have a right to our opinions, but to those of us who have Red Cars. . . . . .Viva La RED!!!!!!!!
...What Perkie said! ;-)
Perkchiro 11/16/2007, 07:58 PM "Repainting it red is cheaper, easier, and faster, but Brittany Blue is a rare and IMHO a more sophisticated color."
It's Ok Arlie, I understood the first time I read it. Very clearly understood, no need to explain it.
Mosesatm 11/16/2007, 08:08 PM "Repainting it red is cheaper, easier, and faster, but Brittany Blue is a rare and IMHO a more sophisticated color."
It's Ok Arlie, I understood the first time I read it. Very clearly understood, no need to explain it.
Good, it sounded to me like you misunderstood the definition of "more". Glad we're on the same page!
CALIF GIRL 11/16/2007, 08:36 PM I gotta go with viva la red....
But seriously it is your car and only you can decide what color fits you and your car best.....
My car was repainted recently. Prior to the repaint it had the paint you see in this picture on it. It was sanded to bare metal all body work done and then painted....... I loved the way she looked.
My garage caught fire and the car was in it. The paint was bubbled, and plastic was melted on it. So it went to the shop for another paint job. This time they did all the work.
The new paint job cost about $9,000. She came out of the shop looking just as good as before the fire.
A lot of the price is labor. My first paint cost way less because I took it to bare metal myself. The more prep you do yourself the less the labor will cost you when you take it in for the paint.
Perkchiro 11/16/2007, 08:36 PM I'm sorry Arlie but that definition of "more" has been a tough one for me to grasp. Thanks for clearing that up for me!!! I guess that the color Blue, now being "more" sophisticated than the color Red, makes perfect sense and it means that both are equally sophisticated. Is that right?
Hey Arlie, I'm just yanking your chain. I'm in a mischievous mood this evening.
PNewitt 11/16/2007, 09:33 PM Oh, Boy....the choice of color....
Before I discuss "color", let me just add that when you read about the true rarity of these cars today, you'll want to go back to original--no matter what color your CS is, or was...
'68 Shelby owners would pretty much go back to original, regardless of the color, because of their values, and the importance of going back to what it was. Many classic cars have returned to their original color--regardless if it's popular today or not, because of that car's historical significance. We're approaching that "historical" thinking quickly.
I see some spirited ribbing here about the color red. Ferrari likes it, and "Little Red" was..umm.well....RED!
The color choices for 1968 Fords were chosen in mid-'67, and lime gold was popular (such as appliances, etc.), and one should consider the culture back then as to how the Ford color palatte was chosen.
There were a few of the Mustang colors that were also used on the Lincolns, and Cougars. EVERY color has it's place, and when you put it in context, you'll know that it's the right color. Sure, tons of old, chalky lime green Mustangs were painted red. Red seems like that sure-fire sportscar color, and maybe it's become a cliche'. That's not to say that Candyapple Red is less sophisticated than any other color. To say "sophisticated", it might mean colors like they use on BMWs, Jags or Aston Martins--which used on a '68 Mustang, would look out of place, or too custom by comparison to an original color.
However, ANY of the other colors, when they are in factory condition, are impressive. It's the Shelby fiberglass, and the stripes that will set off any color choice. The addition of styled steel Rally wheels, and perhaps a vinyl top in black or white adds even more. The interior color has a lot to do with how it looks, too.
It's all about context. 1968 context. Think of some of the 1955-57 T-Bird colors. "Coral" reminds me of thousand island salad dressing! But--it's a proper color for that period. Today, Ford brought back Lime Gold, with Legendary Lime. Same color. Go figure.
So, I'd go with the Brittany Blue. (psst...it was used on racing Ford GT-40s).
Paul N.
p.s. this discussion begs the additional question: "should I completely tear the car down and rebuild it?"...(after 40 years?)
joedls 11/16/2007, 10:03 PM I see some spirited ribbing here about the color red. Ferrari likes it, and "Little Red" was..umm.well....RED!
Did someone say Ferrari Red? As in Rosso Fuoco?
Mosesatm 11/16/2007, 10:15 PM Did someone say Ferrari Red? As in Rosso Fuoco?
That's a great looking car, Joe. As is this one.
John McGilvary 11/16/2007, 11:28 PM My GT/CS was repainted Candy Apple Red a while back (10-15 years). The paint looks decent still, a few chips here and there but nothing bad. Originally the car was Brittany Blue. I was looking at the other Marti reports and was noticing that there arent a lot of Brittany Blue GT/CS's on the site. Should I repaint mine to the original or just leave well enough alone? Also, how much should I expect to pay for a good paint job? Thanks
Tony
Tony,
I say, " Whatever Turns Your Crank ". Red is cool.
As for me Brittany Blue was my choice out of all the colors 39 years ago when I bought my CS and it still is.
John
joedls 11/16/2007, 11:46 PM That's a great looking car, Joe. As is this one.
Thanks, Arlie. That sure is a beautiful GT/CS. Whose is it?
wally05 11/17/2007, 12:15 AM You know, I was thinking the same thing about my GT/CS. Really, after a paintjob, it would be one heck of a show car. I wouldn't know whether to take it back to the original lime or have it repainted acapulco blue (gorgeous color btw).
Korey
Perkchiro 11/17/2007, 06:37 AM That's a great looking car, Joe. As is this one.
Hey, that car looks familiar..........Thanks!!!:wink:
ahainline 11/17/2007, 09:03 AM Is there any bodywork to do on the car? Dents, body rust, floors, fiberglass repair?
Do you want a show quality job that is hand sanded and buffed, or driver quality that may have a little orange peel?
Are you going to strip off all the old paint or paint over it?
If you have it stripped are you going to do it with a razor blade, are you going to have it chemically strippped, or blasted?
How many paint jobs are on the car now?
thanks for all the responses guys.. I know it will be a while before I worry about the repaint but it is good to get other perspectives so that I can start planning. I guess a lot of it depends on how far do I want to get into making it original.. b/c if I go back to the brittany blue and continue with the originality theme.. then I am going to have to redo the interior back to blue (currently black) etc... could quickly spiral out of control. but to answer a few questions..
Is there any bodywork to do on the car? No body work would need to be done, its completely rust/dent free.
Do you want a show quality job that is hand sanded and buffed, or driver quality that may have a little orange peel? Definately a show quality paint, no sense in doing it if it isnt going to be perfect.
Are you going to strip off all the old paint or paint over it? I do believe it was stripped the last time it was painted.. so I dont know what would be best here.
If you have it stripped are you going to do it with a razor blade, are you going to have it chemically strippped, or blasted? Again, depending on cost and efficiency I guess.. w/e is best.
How many paint jobs are on the car now? 1, looked at the chips and it is a white colored primer underneath.. no blue
Tony
robert campbell 11/17/2007, 10:07 AM Tony,
Thread kinda took a turn didn’t it!!! Joe saw that immediately!!! I thought for a minute that it was democrats verses republicans!!!
Lots of good info in it though. It is amazing the cost of a good paint job. Even a driver one. The critical information you need to supply is how much do YOU want to do by yourself? If you are thinking of a full rotisserie job with you dropping the keys off and coming back late, better get some serious green out. $15 to $20k. I have a contact here in the Northwest that does this for people, and mostly for Shelby’s. And at the same time he will do all mechanical work and new interior and chrome and on and on…… Those get to be $50k and better projects.
I would say if you can disassemble and reassemble the car yourself, you can shop around for the $5k to $6k job that will be a very nice job. You car deserves to have the windows out and the interior out to ensure it is not a “tape and paint” job. Engine out, fenders and doors off, and the backend completely disassembled, Headlight doors removed from the front fender. A driver can stay off the rotisserie.
Huge project, but very manageable in your own garage. Most wives do not mind if you store freshly painted fenders and doors on the living room couch during the holidays…. It kinda helps the marriage blossom and grow into ………. A big weed…… Unless you married my wife. She loves the cars more than I do!!!
Rob
PNewitt 11/17/2007, 10:33 AM A couple of quick points about body prep on a CS.
- do not sand off the "witness line" on the side scoops. This is a seam line near the front of the scoop, where the opening meets the body.
- MCA and other club rules desire a paint job that has some orange peel in it. of course, it's your call; just so you know.
- When obtaining the color for painting, be very "picky" about it being close to original. Some still use the Ditzler and Dupont color codes. Don't settle for "close enough".
Good Luck! Sounds exciting!!
Paul N.
gazrox 11/17/2007, 08:56 PM Once my rebuild is completed I'll go back to original color - seafoam green. I've ordered my interior - again, back to original color of ivy gold. I figure that there were not too many cars with this color combo so in that regard it should be quite unique. I haven't seen too many in this site's gallery either, so I agree with Paul N.
Plus, my wife loves seafoam green - and she's the boss eh! LOL
I had to forfeit many brownie points to get her to agree to this purchase and rebuild so I gotta toe the line when it comes to this car's color!
Gary
nfrntau 11/18/2007, 06:06 AM I guess I can chime in here a bit. I took mine down to bare nothing (chemical stripped) and went back with the original color, Alcapulco Blue. I spent many an evening with the delema stripes or no stripes. In the end I chose to add the stripes and go with what made me happy. The purists will think it's a waste of money, paint and a possible good restoration. Some will think it looks cool and others won't care one way or the other.
On the cost issue, I have done all the work myself except the final bodywork and paint. My cost to date for panel replacement, supplies, body work and paint is $8,132. If you decide to do the full retoration, figure out what you think it's going to cost and double it. That should get you pretty close to your final. I anticipate that I will be very close to this $$ estimate when I'm finished.
I might add that I have upgraded a few things like suspension and steering so I could have kept costs a little bit lower for the project.
Unlike Rob, my wife will not let me keep parts on the couch, I do however have free riegn on the garage and one spare bedroom. If you do the complete restoration be aware that you will need plenty of storage space to hold all you parts in some manner that you can get to the parts you need when going back together.
robert campbell 11/18/2007, 09:11 AM Storage for freshly painted stuff that cannot get a nick! Doors, hood, fenders, trunk lids. And lots of baggies with a note in them for were that small part or bolt goes!! Kitchen pantry is good for organization those small parts.... Just kidding! Any bed is great for resting a painted part safely!
What goes around comes around. Lots of green and gold shades out there in the past couple years on new cars. Most lime gold cars we saw were oxidized so bad they were flat in color. A fresh application of this paint is very pretty! I used to be a black only interior guy. Anymore I would like to sea a color.
Seafoam green with ivy interior! That will be beautiful and hugely unique!!
Rob
Perkchiro 11/19/2007, 08:00 AM Storage for freshly painted stuff that cannot get a nick! Doors, hood, fenders, trunk lids. And lots of baggies with a note in them for were that small part or bolt goes!! Kitchen pantry is good for organization those small parts.... Just kidding! Any bed is great for resting a painted part safely! Rob
"Bag and Tag" is the theme for restoration enthusiasts. I used several boxes of zip lock bags and labeled boxes when I dismantled my car. Those boxes of new parts and freshly painted parts went everywhere in my house. I had parts under the bed, stacked in the corner of my bedroom, in my guest room closet and study. I had to erect new shelving in the garage too. My wife was pretty patient with it all, even though most of it didn't go with the home decor. :smile:
franklinair 11/19/2007, 11:52 AM According to Marti data from a report I have, 34,587 were Lime Gold, 18,369 with the paint/trim codes, 4,118 were C/S's. I'd say the odds are pretty high that MANY C/S's were originally Lime Gold. (I've always believed Ford bought 50 million gallons of that color, based on the number of cars painted that color!) Mine was originally Lime Gold, color changed to Meadowlark Yellow & Black interior. I prefer it. It's a split decision among enthusiasts to remain original or color change. I opted for the change, but Paul made a VERY good point about retaining originality as these cars get older and more rare. Good Luck, whichever your decision.
Neil Hoppe
BroadwayBlue 11/19/2007, 12:14 PM According to Marti data from a report I have, 34,587 were Lime Gold, 18,369 with the paint/trim codes, 4,118 were C/S's. I'd say the odds are pretty high that MANY C/S's were originally Lime Gold. (I've always believed Ford bought 50 million gallons of that color, based on the number of cars painted that color!) ...
Neil Hoppe
I noticed that number the other day comparing the Marti Report on my old 302 (originally Lime Gold now Acapulco Blue) to my 289 (originally and still Acapulco Blue).
19,886 was the Acapulco Blue number with only 3,628 with the Paint/Trim code.
I was surprised at how many more Lime Gold cars were built over Acapulco Blue.
wally05 11/19/2007, 01:50 PM I noticed that fact too, Rich. But I do like the color. I'd probably keep it blue. :)
ahainline 11/20/2007, 06:47 AM anyone with Brittany Blue know how many were made? I have my Marti but it is just the basic one and doesnt give me that information I dont think.
BroadwayBlue 11/20/2007, 07:07 AM The Marti Report will show you the total number of Mustangs painted that color not just California Specials.
Not sure if you are looking for all or just Cal Specials.
There must be someone with a Brittany Blue marti posted on the marti thread I'm sure.
PFSlim 11/20/2007, 10:35 AM Okay. I will chime in. As most of you know, we restored our car from a mess. We had to replace more panels than we kept - we had to. Once all panels went back on, we sprayed a sandable primer (called "All You Ever Need") which was supplied to us by our painter. We sprayed on 3 coats on the entire car, sanded down to metal. Finally, a finish primer was sprayed on before we went to color.
Most of the comments I get about my car when we take it to shows is how perfect the reflection is in the paint. In other words, everything you see in a reflection on the door looks 100% clear. The painters I have spoken to attribute that to the 3 coats of sandable primer. Is it alot of work? YES!! Would I do it again?? In a heartbeat.
In the end, I think our car looks very nice and since I am not a body and paint guy, I just know it is nice. However, I have had many paint guys look at our car and state they would love to have their name associated with our car. It is a great feeling.
Anyway - just rambling. If you decide to repaint the car, I do believe this information would be beneficial.
Paul
PNewitt 11/22/2007, 10:48 AM Perhaps you could show us a few close ups of your paint job?? I'm curious to see how that turned out. I know that seeing it in person would be the way to go, but anything to illustrate how it looks would be inspiring (showing reflections, depth, lighting, etc..).
thanks!
Paul N.
|