Thanks for your thoughtful words on this subject. Yes, this new musclecar era is, and will test the acceptance from the older, original marques; considered "classic".
The purpose of this thread was to aire out the thoughts about the new and old versions. When Detroit comes out with these revitalized names, they do it from a marketing standpoint, probably not realizing the a stir it might bring (I still make a smirk when I see the "Hemi" nameplate on a new Magnum...since the owner's never seen or heard a REAL 440 Hemi to know what it is..).
If it's any consolation, there's always been "rifts" between eras of automobiles and whatever time frame they're from. I remember back about 1979-80, the 1965-66 Mustangers didn't really "accept" the '67-68's, or anything newer. They thought that the original Mustang was about it. In April '64, no one was calling the new "1965 Mustang" a classic...that didn't happen until 1978 (the 1964-1/2 designation didn't begin until 1979, either).
And...the 1955-57 T-Bird owners thought the "squarebirds" of '59-60 weren't real T-Birds...much less anything newer. You can pretty much pick any auto, and you'll find a bias within the ranks. Consider the street rodder phrase from long ago "anything past '49 ain't worth it" (along with the one " if it don't GO, chrome it").
So, this thinking is everywhere. Good or bad, it's just the nature of the hobby. Purely subjective.
I think that we have the advantage of (in a "Dr. Phil sorta way"-LOL) addressing this issue, and at least talking about it. I started this thread NOT to suggest or promote any specific agenda, but to hear from owners of both periods. I didn't expect to change any minds; just take advantage of the forums here to see what folks had to say. I've been concerned about how the new CS owners felt about the older cars (and owners), and I think overall, we're all on the same page.
Think about it....there will be a day when the '07 GT/CS will be at a car show as a 40 yr. old car (if there still is gas), and someone will be unhappy that a hydrogen-electric-powered 2047 Mustang GT/CS-H is appearing at their car show.
Whatever happens, the GT/CS name will be a 100 yr. old name. We have ourselves to thank for that--both from the new and old versions.
Paul N.